Women: Like Men, Only Cheaper

by Vivienne Porritt @ViviennePorritt – adapted from 2 blogs first published on Staffrm

 viv7-1What’s the issue?

Women earn less than men in 90% of all employment sectors. British women are paid a fifth less than men, on average, which equates to women earning approximately 80p per £1 than a man earns. This means that, from roughly the second week in November, women work for free compared to men. Even in female dominated professions, the salary gap emerges: men earn more than women on average, especially in leadership roles. 42% of UK women work PT compared to 12% of men with all the subsequent pension issues in later life which raises more significant issues. Mothers in the UK earn, on average, 4% less after each child and fathers’ salaries increase by an average of 6% – the so-called motherhood penalty and fatherhood bonus.

An important source is the 2012 double blind study where male and female university staff, looking to hire a laboratory manager, rated identical CVs, one from John and one from Jennifer. You know the outcome. John was hired by more people and offered a higher starting salary than Jennifer.

It’s a complex issue: an excellent Freakonomics podcast and transcript  highlights this. To me, it  boils down to this excellent question asked by Barack Obama in January 2016:

What kind of example does paying women less set for our sons and daughters?

What’s behind this issue?

There have been improvements.  Women aged 22-39 working more than 30 hours a week now earn more than men on average. But it goes downhill from there. Here’s a fascinating article which highlights a key issue for women education leaders,  negotiating your salary.

Men are 4 times as likely as women to negotiate their first salary offer. From cars to salaries, women don’t ask for what they are worth or like negotiating, likening it to going to the dentist whereas men liken it to wrestling!

Edudatalab (www.educationdatalab.org.uk) has highlighted the outcomes for FULL-TIME women leaders in schools because we lack the #confidence to ask and negotiate. With performance related pay for all, it will get worse.

viv7-2.jpgSo even in a profession which has, as Russell Hobby when at National Association of Head Teachers, said, ‘one of the largest density of female chief executives in the country’, full time women leaders are paid less.

We must challenge and change this.

Individual solutions

Women need to apply for leadership roles. A McKinsey report highlighted that the most powerful force holding women back is entrenched beliefs. These include the unconscious or conscious bias of both male and female managers and women’s own self-limiting beliefs. 22% of women (cf to 13%of men) don’t want to fail so more women than men don’t apply for jobs if they don’t meet all the criteria.

Women need to take the risk and apply for more leadership roles than they currently do and so learn from the feedback. One belief most women hold is that practice makes perfect so take advantage of that and get applying!

We also need to ask for the salary we deserve in a new role or through performance related pay. It’s important to know this is possible and, indeed, organisations expect it. A Harvard Business Review article titled ‘ Nice Girls don’t ask’ offers useful advice about why we find this hard and how to improve. More advice is available from the website Take the Lead.

If fear or lack of confidence or self-worth stops us, practice can improve this. What’s the worst that can happen? You can also seek development opportunities in how to have these conversations or ask your mentor for advice.

Systemic solutions

The above McKinsey report says only systemic change makes the real difference. Commitment from the top, diversity programmes and targeted behavioural change are not scalable and bursts of activity are not always sustainable. It needs the transformation of culture, processes and practices to bring about change and such transformation is often driven by imperatives. A powerful reason to change can be to retain the best talent and that’s a pressing need in education. An example of successful change in practices is that Google increased family leave from 3-5 months and made it fully paid leading to a 50% drop in mothers who left the company.

By March 2018, in England, all companies employing 250 employees must publish gender salary statistics, including all bonus payments. This includes academy chains and universities.  If we need more than a moral motive, then education organisations must address this issue or be shamed. Governors and trustees of individual schools, academies, colleges and universities can start by asking for this information now.

I wa #10%braver and negotiated my salary for the first time in my career when I moved to a university and I applied for salary increases at every stage after that, citing ppropriate evidence and impact.  It surprised some people but always had a positive effect.  I recommend this to every woman leader in education. You know you are worth it.

1 Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s